Better Business Bureau: Puppy Scams Fall, but Individual Losses Rise

Wolf in Puppy’s Clothing

Puppy scams remain consistently profitable for scammers because their multi-tiered setup allows them to convincingly go back to a consumer several times to ask for money. Total losses in 2022 are down by one-third compared to the peak of more than $3 million during the pandemic in 2020/2021, according to BBB Scam Tracker.

However, individual monetary losses in puppy scams are climbing, with an average loss of $850 in 2022, up 60 percent since 2017, when BBB began tracking fake online pet sellers.

Pet scams historically make up 25 percent of all online shopping frauds reported to BBB and are tracking to be down slightly for 2022 at 18 percent.

Puppy scammers lure people with fake websites and promises of cute puppies, then ask for more money for shipping or special crates. Consumers say it is easy to be swept up in the emotions of the moment when buying a pet and push forward despite reservations.

According to BBB Scam Tracker, instead of receiving a 9-week-old golden retriever puppy, one victim lost a total of $350 on a false puppy advertisement posted on Craigslist. The initial cost for the puppy was listed as $175. The seller told the woman he had multiple buyers, but he would hold the puppy for a refundable deposit of $50. The victim sent the payment using Venmo and received another invoice requesting an additional $125. The seller gave the victim his phone number, residential address, and a time to pick up the dog. Ninety minutes before picking up the pet, the woman called to find out the phone number wasn’t in service and the address was fake. She was out the money and sadly didn’t have the puppy she was expecting.