Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags

Rep. Young Signs on to Letter to Major General Cleveland


A letter signed by Rep. Young and many of his colleagues on Dec. 10 addressed to Major General Cleveland, Commander, Special Operations Command Central expresses strong disagreement with the decision to pursue first a non-judicial punishment and now a full court-martial against three Navy SEALS - Matthew McCabe, Jonathan Keefe, and Julio Huertas on charges of assault against Ahmed Hashim Abed.

The text of the letter appears below:

Congress of the United States
Washington, DC 20515

December 10, 2009

Major General Charles T. Cleveland
Commander, Special Operations Command Central
U.S. Central Command
7115 South Boundary Boulevard
MacDill AFB, FL 33621-5101

Dear General Cleveland:

We are writing to express our strong disagreement with the decision of your officers to pursue first a non-judicial punishment and now a full court-martial against three Navy SEALS - Matthew McCable, Jonathan Keefe and Julio Huertas - on charges of assault aginst Ahmed Hashim Abed - at one point one of the most wanted terrorits in Iraq.

In March 2004, Fallujah, Iraq was a hub of insurgent activity. Four American civilians working as contractos were ambushed and killed; their bodies were mutiliated and burned, then dragged through the streets and hung from a bridge over the Euphrates River - one of the most horrific outrages perpetrated on Americans in the last decade. The made widely identified as the mastermind of that attack, as well as other attacks on United States and coaltion troops in Iraq, is Ahmed Hashim Abed.

For over five years Abed evaded capture until Matthew McCabe, Jonathan Keefe and Julio Huertas finally brought him to justice. Instead of being hailed as heroes, these brave Americans are being vilified for allegedly assaulting Abed once he was in custody. First, press repoerts raise significant doubts about whether Abed was actually in SEAL custody when his alleged minor injuruies occurred. Second, al-Quaeda's own handbook instructs their operatives to allege detainee abuse if detained by American forces. In fact, al-Quaed operatives are trained to self-inflict injuruies for the sole purpose of accusing U.S. forces of abuse. We've seen repeated cases of this since the conflicts in Iraq and Afghanistan began.

General, surely you agree that we are in aa war that we must win. Our military presonnel are putting their lives on the line every day trying to track down terrorists who want to indiscriminately kill Americans. Our troops and your SEALs need to be bold and decisive in combat; not looking over their shoulder fearing legal jeopardy for every action or gesture. In this case in particular, there is more than enough doubt as to whether these SEALs committed any wrongdoing at all. In our opinion, prosecutorial discreion should have been exercised. Failinbg that, we respectfully and strongly urge you to exercise your leadership authority, stop the impending court martial and exonerate these men.

We await your promopt response.


(signed by 41 members of Congress)

Navy SEALs Co-signers
1. Aderholt
2. Akin
3. Barton
4. Bilbray
5. Bishop
6. Blackburn
7. Calvert
8. Capito
9. Coble
10. Cole
11. Diaz-Balart, M.
12. Fallin
13. Gingrey
14. Graves
15. Hall
16. Hunter
17. King
18. Kirk
19. Latta
20. Manzullo
21. Marchant
22. McCotter
23. Myrick
24. Neugebauer
25. Nunes
26. Olson
27. Pence
28. Pitts
29. Posey
30. Roe
31. Rohrabacher
32. Ros-Lehtinen
33. Royce
34. Schock
35. Shadegg
36. Shuster
37. Smith, C.
38. Thompson
39. Wamp
40. Young, D.

CC: Hon. Barack Obama, Hon. Robert Gates, Adml. Mike Mullen

Edit Module

Add your comment: